Which accounting package is better for bookkeeping? MYOB or Xero?
We hear people talk about how good MYOB and Xero are. But which one is best for your business? Choosing which accounting package when asking colleagues and professionals has become like asking which is the better v8 Supercar maker, Holden or Ford? Who is going to win State of Origin, the Blues or the Maroons? Or which is better to shop at, Coles or Woolworths?
Bookkeeping is a critical part of any small business, so we shouldn’t be deciding which accounting package to use simply by the preference of others. Let’s look at what you will need to consider when deciding.
1. Who will be doing your bookkeeping?
If you have a bookkeeper who will be doing all of your bookkeeping for you, then the decision of which accounting package may already be decided. Many bookkeepers now only train in using one accounting package, be it MYOB or Xero. If you or one of your staff will be doing the bookkeeping, they may only be trained in one or neither of the two accounting packages.
2. Do you have access or good connection to the internet?
Being able to access the internet is a crucial part of deciding whether to use MYOB or Xero. Xero is a cloud based only package, therefore you can only use it while you are connected to the internet. So if you have poor or no internet connectivity, then Xero may not be the best accounting package for you. MYOB have accounting packages that do not require to always be connected to the internet. You can work on the business file without being connected and upload it later. Read further as to the different packages within Xero and MYOB.
3. Useability.
If you intend to do your own bookkeeping, Xero is definitely a much more user friendly accounting package. Their training tutorials are done on video for each module of the accounting package. The core package is very simple in features and to navigate. MYOB can feel a little clunky to use if you are not familiar with it. It can be jammed with features creating confusion when trying to find and do things.
The counter to this is MYOB will have many of the features you will require later and these are already included in the package. Xero is very light on features, meaning later you may feel it lacking in functionality and will require add-ons to access or improve on features. We will discuss add-ons later.
4. Packages within the Packages.
Both Xero and MYOB have different packages within the packages. For example MYOB has AccountRight and MYOB Essentials. While Xero has Starter, Standard and Premium. We will be discussing MYOB AccountRight and MYOB Premium.
An example of this is Payroll. MYOB AccountRight has an unlimited number of employees you can create in the payroll. Xero is limited in the core package to only 5 employees. MYOB AccountRight has job costing included while Xero projects is a fee per month.
So understanding what you will need now and in the future is important in deciding whether to purchase MYOB or Xero.
5. Add-ons
Accounting packages are becoming more about the add-ons then about the accounting package…. and for good reason!
Add-ons are additional applications that you can use to ‘attach’ to the core MYOB or Xero accounting package. What’s great about add-ons is that they can essentially allow you to customise and supercharge your accounting package to your business needs. The only thing is being able to know what add-ons you will need and what they can do. MYOB has some 400 add-ons while Xero has over 1,000. The categories of add-ons can vary based upon industry, function or category. The ability to negotiate which add-ons you need has become an industry within itself.
Also the need and cost of add-ons. As previously discussed, Xero is a very light but very simple package. It has become a darling of the technology world for its REST API (Tech talk for ‘it connects with other software applications very well’) as it allows software developers to create applications to add features to the core Xero package, hence the greater number of add-ons with Xero. Again using Payroll as an example, after 5 employees you will need to pay for more employee licences with Xero or look to using and purchasing another add-on that will facilitate the number of employees you need now and in the future.
Add-ons are generally priced as a monthly subscription and can then increase with features and licences. This needs to be a factor when considering price which will be discussed later. Many add-ons now integrate with both MYOB and Xero, which is something to consider later when we discuss current and future needs.
6. Current and future needs
We sometimes buy only considering what we need now, without considering what we need in the future. Consider what your needs are not only now but later in your decision. Will your change in needs be accommodated by either MYOB or Xero package you’re using now or will you need to upgrade the package or purchase an add-on later?
While we cannot predict the future we can consider it for our current purchasing decisions.
For example, you may use an add-on that is of tremendous value to your business. But you may decide to change from MYOB to Xero or Xero to MYOB. If the add-on integrates with both accounting packages then great, you can change and continue using the add-on. But if it doesn’t then you may have to make the decision of either changing accounting packages as well add-ons, or keeping the add-on and therefore staying with the same accounting package.
7. Price
As discussed, both MYOB and Xero offer different packages within their suite of products. Both products will offer a monthly subscription service. What is also needed are any add-ons that allow you to use the package for your everyday needs or to allow you to supercharge parts of your business by attaching customised add-ons to save money or time or make you money. The price of the packages should not be considered on its own and should be considered as part of a number of factors including add-ons, cost savings, time savings and increased benefits. To find out more about pricing visit the MYOB Price Plans and Xero Price Plans.
8. Still don’t know which accounting package to choose. MYOB or Xero?
Foley Business Management is both a MYOB Partner and Xero Certified Advisor. What this means for our client’s is that we can assist them to make a more informed business decision in what accounting package is best for them. We take into consideration all of the above factors plus many more when advising you which accounting package is the most appropriate for you and your business. Choosing which accounting package to use is critical in your business success. Do you want to make such a crucial decision without the right advice? Then contact Foley Business Management to discuss how we can help you make the right decision.
All information in this article was correct at the time of writing.



